What year was the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL built?

The house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL was built in 1963.

What type of house is at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL?

At the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL type Residence for Single Family.

Does the home at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL have a sales history?

The last sale of a house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL was in 2001 for $515,000.

Have there been any fire incidents near the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL?

The last fire incident at the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL was in 2017. Other fire incidents of this house are available at the link.

Search address For sale For rent

Summerland Key, FL
Bay Shore Drive
456 Bay Shore Drive

456 Bay Shore Dr Summerland Key, FL 33042 / 5335

Map

Residence for Single Family

(UPDATED: 06/10/2025)

2 Beds
2 Baths
0.8 acres

Property Report

Information about property on 456 Bay Shore Dr, Summerland Key FL, 33042-5335. Find out owner contacts, building history, price, neighborhood at Homemetry Address Directory.

Property Details

The single-family property is situated at 456 Bay Shore Drive, Summerland Key, Florida.

Facts

Built in 1963
Lot size 0,8 acres
Construction Masonry
Stories 1 story
Last remodel year 1987
Foundation Piling
Heating & Cooling
Cooling Wall
Exterior Home Features
Exterior material Vinyl
Exterior walls Other
Roof type Shingle (Not Wood)
Parking & Garage
Parking Garage
Parking spaces 2

Listing info

Last sold Jun 2001 for $515,000

Householders and Tenants for 456 Bay Shore Dr, Summerland Key FL

Possible residents contact details

Person Name	Phone Number	Additional Info
Catherine J Sutton Age: 44	305-872-****
Nathan J Walton Age: 61	305-872-****
Samuel F Sutton Age: 39		Residential status: Homeowner
Stephanie Sutton Age: 71	305-872-****

Businesses

Organization	Phone Number	Additional Info
SUTTON CHARTERS, LC		Type of Business: Florida Limited Liability Company
SUTTON INDUSTRIES, LC		Type of Business: Florida Limited Liability Company

Purchase History

Date	Event	Price	Source	Agents
06/11/2001	Sold	$515,000	Public records

Cost estimate history

Year	Tax	Assessment	Market
2014	$9,694	$946,384	$946,384

Where is 456 Bay Shore Dr, Summerland Key FL located on map?

456 Bay Shore Dr Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025

11 Dec 2017 Building fires

456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key FL

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Area of Origin —

Closet

Bay Shr Dr Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025

11 Dec 2017 Building fires

456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key FL

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Area of Origin —

Closet

Properties Nearby

Street Address	Residens/Landlords

View Neighbors

Summerland Key, FL
Bay Shore Drive
456 Bay Shore Drive

Bay Shore Drive

Houses for Sale on Bay Shore Drive (2)

Summerland Key, FL

Houses for Sale on Summerland Key, FL (304)

Recently Sold Homes on Summerland Key, FL (89)

Houses for Rent on Summerland Key, FL (45)

Recent rentals on Summerland Key, FL (40)

Browse homes in Summerland Key, FL

Street Address
134 TORTUGA LN, Summerland Key FL
21575 OLD STATE ROAD 4A, Summerland Key FL
346 SANDY CIR, Summerland Key FL
20786 5TH ST, Summerland Key FL

FAQ about the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL

What year was the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL built? The house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL was built in 1963.
What type of house is at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL? At the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL type Residence for Single Family.
Does the home at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL have a sales history? The last sale of a house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL was in 2001 for $515,000.
Have there been any fire incidents near the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL? The last fire incident at the house at 456 Bay Shr Dr, Summerland Key, FL was in 2017. Other fire incidents of this house are available at the link.

NOTICE: You may not use SpamRoom or the information it provides to make decisions about employment, credit, housing or any other purpose that would require Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance. SpamRoom is not a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA) as defined by the FCRA and does not provide consumer reports.