Property Details

As is shown in our records this property is placed at 59 Bay Avenue, Eastport, NY.

Facts

Built in 2000
Lot size 1,48 acres
Pool Pool (yes)
Bedrooms 3
Stories 2 story with basement
Basement Full Basement
Structure type Colonial
Heating & Cooling
Heat type Central
Exterior Home Features
Exterior walls Wood
Parking & Garage
Parking Garage
Parking spaces 2

Misc

Units 1

Listing info

Last sold Jan 2006 for $663,500

Features

Fireplace
Construction quality: 6.0

Householders and Tenants for 59 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Possible residents contact details

Person Name	Phone Number	Additional Info
Edward J Matthaei Age: 73	631-325-****
Eva M Salerno Age: 68
Gary J Mathews Age: 68	631-325-****
Isobel J Matthaei Age: 73	631-325-****
Karen A Pranis Age: 60		Residential status: Homeowner
Michelle D Matthaei Age: 49
Theodora A Gallo	631-325-****
Theodora Salerno	631-325-****
Victor Kostuk	631-325-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Construction and Extraction Occupations

Purchase History

Date	Event	Price	Source	Agents
06/04/2003	Sold	$460,000	Public records
10/27/2000	Sold	$310,000	Public records

Cost estimate history

Year	Tax	Assessment	Market
2013	N/A	$384,900	N/A

Where is 59 Bay Ave, Eastport NY located on map?

Market Activities

To date, we have no information about market activities in 2025

Mar 2021 Listed for sale

59 Bay Ave

Price history :

$2.2M

Single Family
6,000 sqft
5 beds
6 baths

Jun 2018 Listed for sale

59 Bay Ave

Price history :

$3M

6,000
5 beds
5 baths

Oct 2015 Sold

59 Bay Ave

Price history :

$520K

Single-Family Home
1,600 sqft
1.2 acres
3 beds
2 baths

Bay Ave Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025

18 Mar 2014 Fire, other

20 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Area of Origin —

Function area, other

First Ignition —

Item First Ignited, Other

Heat Source —

Hot ember or ash

10 Feb 2007 Building fires

11 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Area of Origin —

Structural area, other

First Ignition —

Structural member or framing

19 Mar 2006 Brush, or brush and grass mixture fire

44 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Vacant lot

Area of Origin —

Open area - outside; included are farmland, field

22 Sep 2003 Passenger vehicle fire

11 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Vacant lot

Area of Origin —

Structural area, other

First Ignition —

Structural member or framing

59 Bay Ave incidents registered in FEMA
(Federal Emergency Management Agency)

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025

25 Dec 2011 Hazardous condition, other

59 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Bay Ave Incidents registered in FEMA
(Federal Emergency Management Agency)

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025

19 Apr 2014 Outside rubbish fire, other

44 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

29 Oct 2012 Electrical wiring/equipment problem, other

15 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

25 Dec 2011 Hazardous condition, other

59 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

12 Jul 2011 Fuel burner/boiler malfunction, fire confined

52 Bay Ave, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Properties Nearby

Street Address	Residens/Landlords
5 Bay Ave, Eastport, NY 11941-1309 Single Family Residential 2 beds 2 baths Lot: 0.33 acres Built in 1991	Jettrey Baker, Wanda Copenhaver
17 Bay Ave, Eastport, NY 11941-1309 Single Family Residential 3 beds 2 baths 1,374 sqft Built in 1991	EASTEND PIPING, INC, Daniel J Bishon
26 Bay Ave, Eastport, NY 11941-1310 Single Family Residential 2 beds 3 baths 1,166 sqft Built in 2004	Dance Mechanix Inc, Michelle P Montalbano
27 Bay Ave, Eastport, NY 11941-1309 Single Family Residential 3 beds 2 baths Lot: 0.58 acres Built in 2001	Colonial Cottage, Jennifer Cain