Search address For sale For rent

Eastport, NY
401-499
Montauk Highway
457 Montauk Highway

457 Montauk Hwy Eastport, NY 11941 / 1214

(UPDATED: 07/11/2025)

Property Report

Information about property on 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY, 11941-1214. Find out owner contacts, building history, price, neighborhood at Homemetry Address Directory.

Select apt / unit

Property Details

The multi-family property is situated at the end of the street at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY.

Facts

Built in 1991
Lot size 0,93 acres
Rooms 10
Bedrooms 5
Bathrooms 2
Stories 2 story
Basement No Basement
Heating & Cooling
Heat type Central
Exterior Home Features
Exterior material Wood
Exterior walls Siding (Alum/Vinyl)
Roof type Other
Parking & Garage
Parking 0 space

Misc

Units 1

Listing info

Price $499,900
Status For Sale

Features

Dryer
Fireplace
Laundry: In Unit
Construction quality: 6.0
View: Water

Householders and Tenants for 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Possible residents contact details

Person Name	Phone Number	Additional Info
A M Helms	631-325-****
Alice S Jager Age: 66	631-325-****	Residential status: Renter Job: Protective Service Occupations
Barbara A Trypuc
Carl E Helms Age: 105 Apt # 475	631-325-****
David G Papp	631-325-****
Kim Ostrander Age: 64	631-335-****	Email: [email protected]
Maribeth Mallman Age: 43	631-325-****
Mary H Mallman Age: 81	631-325-****
Matthew R Vestuto Age: 73	631-742-****	Residential status: Homeowner
Michelle S Vestuto Age: 70	631-742-****	Residential status: Homeowner
Robert Sarubbi Age: 64
Robert Tangolics	631-325-****
Steven Garms	631-325-****
Vanessa Bullock	631-325-****

Units - Who lives at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Carl E Helms

11941-1214

Purchase History

Date	Event	Price	Source	Agents
01/21/2015	Price Change -$56K (-10.1%)	$499,900	Landmark Realty of L.I., Inc.
12/11/2014	Price Change -$44K (-7.3%)	$556,000	Landmark Realty of L.I., Inc.
08/13/2014	Price Change -$29K (-4.6%)	$599,990	Landmark Realty of L.I., Inc.
07/16/2014	Price Change -$20K (-3.1%)	$629,000	Landmark Realty of L.I., Inc.
05/31/2014	Price Change -$10K (-1.5%)	$649,000	Landmark Realty of L.I., Inc.
03/30/2014	Price Change	$659,000	Landmark Realty of L.I., Inc.

PURCHASE HISTORY 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Cost estimate history

Year	Tax	Assessment	Market
2013	N/A	$413,300	N/A

Where is 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY located on map?

Market Activities

To date, we have no information about market activities in 2025

Nov 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$10,000

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Nov 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$1,900

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Oct 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$10,000

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Oct 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$1,900

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Sep 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$10,000

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Sep 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$2,100

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Sep 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$25.2K

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

May 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$20K

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

May 2016 Recent Rent

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$1,900

1675 sqft
2 beds
1.5 baths

457 Montauk Highway In Eastport, This Cottage, Rumored To Be The Oldest House In Eastport, Is...

Mar 2016 Sold

457 Montauk Hwy

Price history :

$390K

Multi-Family Home
3,317 sqft
0.93 acres
3 beds
2 baths

Montauk Hwy Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025

20 May 2016 Building fires

511 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Professional supplies, services

Area of Origin —

Storage area, other

30 Mar 2011 Fire, other

360 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Area of Origin —

Other

14 Dec 2009 Passenger vehicle fire

390 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Highway or divided highway

01 Jan 2009 Building fires

571 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Restaurant or cafeteria

Area of Origin —

Cooking area, kitchen

Montauk Hwy Incidents registered in FEMA
(Federal Emergency Management Agency)

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025

18 Jan 2015 Power line down

525 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Street or road in commercial area

15 Jul 2014 Power line down

358 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

31 Oct 2012 Power line down

207 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Pipeline, power line or other utility right of way

29 Oct 2012 Power line down

415 Montauk Hwy, Eastport NY

Property Use —

Pipeline, power line or other utility right of way

Properties Nearby

Street Address	Residens/Landlords

View Neighbors

Eastport, NY
401-499
Montauk Highway
457 Montauk Highway

Montauk Highway

Houses for Sale on Montauk Highway (3)

Recently Sold Homes on Montauk Highway (4)

Recent rentals on Montauk Highway (6)

Eastport, NY

Houses for Sale on Eastport, NY (41)

Recently Sold Homes on Eastport, NY (178)

Houses for Rent on Eastport, NY (8)

Recent rentals on Eastport, NY (5)

Browse homes in Eastport, NY

Street Address
457 OLD MONTAUK HWY, Eastport NY
391 MONTAUK HWY, Eastport NY
13 LAKEVIEW CT, Eastport NY
2 JESSIE RD, Eastport NY

FAQ about the house at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY

What year was the house at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY built? The house at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY was built in 1991.
What type of house is at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY? At the house at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY type Multi Family.
Have there been any fire incidents near the house at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY? The last fire incident at the house at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY was in 2016. Other fire incidents of this house are available at the link.
Were there any reported FEMA incidents at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY? The last FEMA incident recorded at 457 Montauk Hwy, Eastport, NY was in 2015. Other FEMA incidents registered on Montauk Hwy are available at the link.

NOTICE: You may not use SpamRoom or the information it provides to make decisions about employment, credit, housing or any other purpose that would require Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance. SpamRoom is not a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA) as defined by the FCRA and does not provide consumer reports.