257 Commonwealth Ave Buffalo, NY 14216 / 1809

Map

Residence for Single Family

(UPDATED: 08/20/2025)
  • 6 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 2.608 square feet
Property Report

Information about property on 257 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY, 14216-1809. Find out owner contacts, building history, price, neighborhood at Homemetry Address Directory.

Property Details

A comfortable two-story multi-family estate at 257 Commonwealth Avenue, Buffalo, NY.

Facts

  • Built in 1920
  • Lot size 4,250 sqft
  • Floor size 2,608 sqft
  • Bedrooms 6
  • Stories 2
  • Heating & Cooling
  • Heat type Other
  • Parking & Garage
  • Parking Garage - Detached, 342 sqft

Householders and Tenants for 257 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY

Possible residents contact details

Person Name Phone Number Additional Info
Carolyn F Muscarella Age: 68
716-877-****
Residential status:
Homeowner
Job:
Precision Production Occupations
Christopher M Muscarella Age: 40
Residential status:
Homeowner
Daniel J Muscarella Age: 33
716-877-****
Residential status:
Homeowner
Dietrich Getzin
716-876-****
Janet L Mcdonald
716-835-****
Jeanne M Odonnell Age: 65
716-835-****
Jennifer J Dietrich
Joel M Dietrich Age: 55
Kim A Stobnicki Age: 58
716-662-****
Kimberlee D Mcgrath Age: 47
716-874-****
Kimberlee M Dunlop Age: 47
716-874-****
Larry Scott
716-879-****
Laura J Rott
Lawrence Scott
716-901-****
Residential status:
Renter
Job:
Executive, Administrative, and Managerial Occupations
Mary Plague Age: 106
716-836-****
Job:
Retired
Maureen Stclair
Michael L Muscarella Age: 70
716-877-****
Residential status:
Homeowner
Job:
Precision Production Occupations

Where is 257 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY located on map?

Commonwealth Ave Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025
04 Oct 2019 Outside rubbish fire, other
166 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Exterior balcony, unenclosed porch
First Ignition —
Rubbish, trash, or waste
Heat Source —
Flame/torch used for lighting
18 Apr 2019 Building fires
90 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Wall surface: exterior
First Ignition —
Rubbish, trash, or waste
18 Aug 2018 Outside rubbish, trash or waste fire
275 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Outside area, other
First Ignition —
Chips, including wood chips
Heat Source —
Heat source: other
05 Apr 2007 Passenger vehicle fire
67 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
Street, other

View more

Commonwealth Ave Incidents registered in FEMA
(Federal Emergency Management Agency)

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025
10 Jul 2014 Carbon monoxide incident
311 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
18 Jan 2014 Carbon monoxide incident
210 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
05 Nov 2013 Carbon monoxide incident
267 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
10 Mar 2013 Carbon monoxide incident
248 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling

View more

Commonwealth Ave Crime Incidents History

To date, we have no information about crime incidents in 2025
14 Jul 2017 Theft
1 Block Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Case Number —
17-1950826
Description —
LARCENY/THEFT
28 Jun 2017 Theft
100 Block Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Case Number —
17-2180510
Description —
LARCENY/THEFT
12 May 2017 Theft
1 Block Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Case Number —
17-1320251
Description —
LARCENY/THEFT
12 May 2017 Theft
1 Block Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo NY
Case Number —
17-1320160
Description —
LARCENY/THEFT

View more

Properties Nearby

Street Address Residens/Landlords
11 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2751
Multi-Family Home
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • Lot: 4,680 sqft
  • Built in 1928
 Buffalo Promotions, Michael J Clyde
31 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2751
Multiple Occupancy
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,856 sqft
  • Built in 1925
 Michael A Avillo, Elijah L Jones
88 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2720
Multiple Occupancy
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,710 sqft
  • Built in 1920
 Daniel R Alessi, Bridget M Foley
95 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2751
Multiple Occupancy
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,738 sqft
  • Built in 1920
 Christopher Labella, Brian V Lattimore
129 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2307
Single Family
  • 4 beds
  • 1.5 baths
  • 2,090 sqft
  • Built in 1920
 Mary A Burger, Thomas P Burger
154 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2308
Multi Family
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,876 sqft
  • Built in 1920
 Doris G Cairns, Suzanne E Cairns
162 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2308
Multiple Occupancy
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,472 sqft
  • Built in 1925
 Fraternal Order of Sigma Nu Ch, Christopher Alderson
210 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-2339
Multiple Occupancy
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 2,740 sqft
  • Built in 1925
 Anthony C Battaglia, Daniel J Carraba
238 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216-1810
Multi-Family Home
  • 6 beds
  • 2 baths
  • Lot: 3,776 sqft
  • Built in 1900

Commonwealth Avenue

Recently Sold Homes on Commonwealth Avenue (8)

Recent rentals on Commonwealth Avenue (9)

Buffalo, NY

Houses for Sale on Buffalo, NY (124)

Recently Sold Homes on Buffalo, NY (5000)

Houses for Rent on Buffalo, NY (24)

Recent rentals on Buffalo, NY (2269)

 

FAQ about the house at 257 Commonwealth Ave, Buffalo, NY


NOTICE: You may not use SpamRoom or the information it provides to make decisions about employment, credit, housing or any other purpose that would require Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance. SpamRoom is not a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA) as defined by the FCRA and does not provide consumer reports.