Residents

2 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 2 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

4.5 baths
4,716 sqft
Built in 1970

Facts

Lot size: 2.01 acres

Rooms: 11

Stories: 2

Parking: 484 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
NATIONAL EQUITIES L.T.D. INC		Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation Inactive: 20001227	See Details
Amy B Motschwiller Age: 66	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Homemaker Email: [email protected]
Donald E Motschwiller Age: 67	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Financial Professional
Maxwell S Motschwiller Age: 38	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Professional/Technical Email: [email protected]
Melanie P Motschwiller Age: 36	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]

Learn more

4 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 4 Horse Hill Rd, Lattingtown, NY 11545-2606 · 4 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Michae Stiegelbauer	516-759-****
Samantha L Stiegelbauer Age: 48	516-674-****
Nicole Stiegelblr	516-674-****

Learn more

6 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 6 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

5 beds
5.5 baths
3,152 sqft
Built in 1966

Facts

Lot size: 2 acres

Rooms: 10

Stories: 2

Parking: 440 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Beth Berman
Melissa Berman Age: 56		Job: Service Occupations
Millicent Berman
Cassidy B Tichner Age: 36		Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
Fredric G Tichner Age: 66

Learn more

7 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 7 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

4 beds
2.75 baths
2,305 sqft
Built in 1966

Facts

Lot size: 2.85 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 1

Parking: Garage - Attached, 2 spaces

7 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

For Sale $3,680,000

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Francis P Hill	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
P A Hill Age: 72	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner
William T Hill	516-626-****
Patricia A Hill Age: 72	516-328-****

Learn more

9 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 9 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

4 baths
3,581 sqft
Built in 1968

Facts

Lot size: 2.09 acres

Rooms: 9

Stories: 2

Parking: Garage - Attached

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
P S Motors Inc	516-487-****	Industry: Retails New and Used Automobiles SIC6: 551199 - New and used car dealers, nec	See Details
James E Messineo Age: 75	516-626-****
Jim Messino

Learn more

10 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 10 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

3 baths
3,085 sqft
Built in 1965

Facts

Lot size: 2.16 acres

Rooms: 9

Stories: 2

Parking: 456 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
DAWN SALES CO., INC		Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation Inactive: 19920624	See Details
Frank J Miritello	516-626-****
Regina V Miritello Age: 103	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
Stephanie A Miritello Age: 66	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administration/Managerial Email: [email protected]
Catherine R Walsh Age: 107

Learn more

11 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 11 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

6 beds
6.5 baths
87,120 sqft
Built in 2006

Facts

Lot size: 2 acres

Rooms: 8

Stories: 2

Parking: Garage - Attached

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Anthony D Dibenedetto	516-626-****
James T Dibenedetto Age: 67	845-229-****
Jim Dibenedetto Age: 67	845-229-****
Joseph M Dibenedetto
David J Rifka Age: 58

Learn more

12 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 12 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606 · 12 Horse Hill Rd, Brookville, NY 11545-2606

2 baths
2,525 sqft
Built in 1962

Facts

Lot size: 2.02 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 1

Parking: 484 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Elizabeth D Engle	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Retired
Philip D Engle	516-626-****

Learn more

14 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 14 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

3 baths
2,756 sqft
Built in 1961

Facts

Lot size: 2.02 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 1

Parking: 594 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Caryl Coleman
Arden R Geismar Age: 27	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
Gabrielle S Geismar Age: 31	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
Clara Geismar Age: 64		Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
Lisa R Geismar Age: 57	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]

Learn more

15 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 15 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

3.5 baths
3,995 sqft
Built in 1961

Facts

Lot size: 2 acres

Rooms: 8

Stories: 1

Parking: 552 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
KIMCO REALTY CORP		Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation Inactive: 19970624	See Details
Amy C Dougherty	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Email: [email protected]
Harold M Dougherty	516-626-****
Laura K Dougherty Age: 78	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Professional/Technical Email: [email protected]
John F Duffy Age: 83	631-835-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Executive, Administrative, and Managerial Occupations

Learn more

16 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 16 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Morton F Samet	516-671-****
Thomas J Samet	516-671-****

Learn more

17 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 17 Horse Hill Rd, Brookville, NY 11545-2605 · 17 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

7 beds
8 baths
5,228 sqft
Built in 1962

Facts

Lot size: 2.03 acres

Rooms: 15

Stories: 2

Parking: Garage - Attached, 450 sqft

17 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Sold $2,500,000

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Lh Reporting Service Inc		Industry: Services-Misc	See Details
LORI ROONEY PHOTOGRAPHY, INC		Industry: Photo Portrait StudioPhotographic Studios, Portrait, Nsk Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation	See Details
ROONEY HOLDINGS, INC		Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation	See Details
Joan M Coccia Age: 64
Richard J Coccia Age: 57	516-626-****

Learn more

18 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2645

Alternative address: 18 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2645

4 beds
5 baths
5,234 sqft
Built in 1987

Facts

Lot size: 2.17 acres

Rooms: 8

Stories: 2

Parking: Garage - Attached, 545 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Brookville Clerk	516-626-** 516-626-**	Categories: Local Government Offices Site: villageofbrookville.com	See Details
Brookville, Village of Inc	516-626-****	Industry: Village Government	See Details
HAROLD M DOUGHERTY INC	718-347-****	Industry: Heating & Air Conditioning/hvac	See Details
Joseph Riedman Co	516-354-****	Industry: Plumbing/Heating/Air Cond Contractor	See Details
Kirk P. Warga Plumbing & Heating	516-214-****	Specialties: Central A/C InstallCentral A/C RepairSwamp Cooler InstallSwamp Cooler RepairWindow A/C InstallWindow A/C ServiceOutdoor Mist System InstallMist System RepairCentral Humidifier Repa... Categories: Air ConditioningHeating & Furnace SystemsPlumbing	See Details

Learn more

18A Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY

Alternative address: 18A Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Ahrc Chidren's Main Administration Building	516-626-****	Categories: Local Government Offices	See Details
Brookville Reformed Church Meeting Hall	516-626-****	Categories: Local Government Offices	See Details
Brookville Building Inspector	516-626-****	Categories: Local Government Offices Site: villageofbrookville.com	See Details

Learn more

19 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 19 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

6 beds
4.5 baths
6,700 sqft
Built in 1998

Facts

Lot size: 2.03 acres

Rooms: 12

Stories: 2

Parking: Garage - Attached, 792 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Gary L Brustein	516-626-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Professional/Technical
Jordan L Brustein	516-626-****
Lisa M Brustein Age: 64	516-626-****
Joan M Coccia Age: 64
Joy M Coccia Age: 63	516-293-****

Learn more

20 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 20 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

4 baths
4,433 sqft
Built in 1985

Facts

Lot size: 2 acres

Rooms: 10

Stories: 1

Parking: 720 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
ON BOARD MEDIA, INC		Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation	See Details
Donna Glabman Age: 59		Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administration/Managerial Email: [email protected]
Greg Haggerty	516-676-****
P Turner	516-676-****
Bette S Neuman Age: 76	516-376-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Sales Occupations Email: [email protected]

Learn more

21 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 21 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

5 baths
6,305 sqft
Built in 1983

Facts

Lot size: 2.09 acres

Rooms: 12

Stories: 2

Parking: 713 sqft

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
MODEH ANI LLC		Type of Business: Domestic Limited Liability Company	See Details
Adam H Greenbaum Age: 31	516-484-****	Residential status: Homeowner
Bernard Greenbaum Age: 95	516-484-****
Gloria Greenbaum Age: 92	516-484-****
Irwin M Greenbaum Age: 62	516-484-****

Learn more

29 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2605

Alternative address: 29 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2605

6 beds
4.5 baths
4,954 sqft
Built in 1982

Facts

Lot size: 2.09 acres

Rooms: 9

Stories: 2

Parking: 828 sqft

Sold $2,200,000

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
DUREQUIP, INC		Industry: Business Services at Non-Commercial Site Type of Business: Domestic Business Corporation	See Details
John R Durante	516-626-****
Millie Mattimiro Age: 103

Learn more

32 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 32 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Daniel J Mccauley	516-676-****

Learn more

48 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 48 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
John R Durante	516-626-****

Learn more

56 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown, NY 11545-2606

Alternative address: 56 Horse Hill Rd, Glen Head, NY 11545-2606

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Joseph A Cortese	516-674-****

Learn more

All Market Activities Residents Comparison graphs

Market Activities

To date, we have no information about market activities in 2025

Nov 2023 Sold

29 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$2.2M

Single Family
6 beds
5 baths

Sep 2023 Sold

29 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$2.65M

Single Family
6 beds
5 baths

Jun 2023 Sold

29 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$2.89M

Single Family
6 beds
5 baths

Jun 2022 Listed for sale

7 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$3.68M

Single Family
6 beds
6 baths

Feb 2022 Sold

17 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$2.5M

Single Family
8 beds
8 baths

Jun 2021 Recent Rent

18 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$9,000

Rental
3,224 sqft
4 beds
3 baths

Jun 2021 Sold

17 Horse Hill Rd

Price history :

$2.7M

Single Family
8 beds
8 baths

Incidents registered in Federal Emergency Management Agency

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025

28 Jan 2014 Toxic condition, other

21 Horse Hl Rd, Muttontown NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

15 Apr 2013 Electrical wiring/equipment problem, other

21 Horse Hl Rd, Muttontown NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

28 Aug 2011 Power line down

29 Horse Hl Rd, Muttontown NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

27 Jul 2010 Electrical wiring/equipment problem, other

29 Horse Hl Rd, Muttontown NY

Property Use —

Open land or field

Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown NY

Residents

Facts

Who has lived here

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Who has lived here

Who has lived here

Who has lived here

Market Activities

Incidents registered in Federal Emergency Management Agency

Comparison graphs

House prices on 2-56 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown NY

Total rooms, bathrooms and bedrooms on 2-56 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown NY

Lot size and building area (in sqft) on 2-56 Horse Hill Rd, Muttontown NY

Where is Horse Hl Rd, Muttontown NY located on map?