Residents

1 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 1 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

Lot: 0.5 acres

Facts

Lot size: 0.5 acres

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Joanne L Cavaleiri	631-981-****
Jamie Cavalieri	631-981-****
Carlo Cavalieri Age: 82	631-553-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Production Occupations
Carol Cavalieri Age: 82	631-553-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Production Occupations Email: [email protected]
Joanne Cavalieri Age: 58	631-553-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Production Occupations

Learn more

2 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4214

4 beds
3 baths

Sold $555,555

Learn more

3 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 3 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

4 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.63 acres
Built in 2000

Facts

Lot size: 0.63 acres

Rooms: 8

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Exotic Tango Vacations, LLC		Industry: Single-Family House Construction	See Details
Home Improvements of Long Island Inc	631-461-****	Specialties: Asphalt Shingle Roof InstallFlat Foam / Single Ply Roof InstallMetal Roof InstallRoof Heating Cable InstallNatural Slate Roof InstallNatural Slate Roof RepairTraditional Tile Roof ... Categories: RoofingRoofing Contractors Industry: Single-Family House ConstructionArchitectGutter CleaningGutter RepairRemodelingRoof CleaningRoof Snow RemovalRoofingSidingSkylightsSnow RemovalReplacement Windows Site: homeimprovementsofli.com	See Details
Joseph Cavalieri
Frank M Donadio	631-580-****
B A Tom

Learn more

4 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4214

Alternative address: 4 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4214

3 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.5 acres
Built in 1967

Facts

Lot size: 0.5 acres

Rooms: 6

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

Sold $401,600

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Alan M Otto	631-981-****
Jacqueline P Otto Age: 43	631-981-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Food Preparation and Serving Related Occupations Email: [email protected]
Jeanne M Otto Age: 73	631-981-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Food Preparation and Serving Related Occupations
Martha B Otto Age: 102	631-981-****
Peter Otto		Residential status: Homeowner Job: Food Preparation and Serving Related Occupations

Learn more

7 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 7 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

4 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.88 acres
Built in 1957

Facts

Lot size: 0.88 acres

Rooms: 9

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

For Sale $459,000

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
John Biondi
Gregory Y Gerig Age: 52	516-702-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administrative Support Occupations, Including Clerical Occupations Email: [email protected]
John J Gerig Age: 87	516-702-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administrative Support Occupations, Including Clerical Occupations
Mary M Gerig Age: 48	516-702-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administrative Support Occupations, Including Clerical Occupations
Tammi Gerig

Learn more

8 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 8 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

3 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.3 acres
Built in 1970

Facts

Lot size: 0.3 acres

Rooms: 5

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

Parking: Underground/Basement

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Frank M Donadio	516-395-****
Gregory Y Gerig Age: 52	631-738-****
John J Gerig Age: 87	631-738-****
Mary M Gerig Age: 48	631-738-****
Tammi L Gerig Age: 50	631-738-****

Learn more

10 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 10 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

4 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.5 acres
Built in 1950

Facts

Lot size: 0.5 acres

Rooms: 8

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Jamboree Hot Dogs		Industry: Eating Place	See Details
Loraine M Caraccia Age: 67	631-467-****
Lorraine Caraccia	631-553-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Service Occupations Email: [email protected]
Michael J Caraccia Age: 71	631-553-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Service Occupations
Mike Caraccia	631-255-****

Learn more

12 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 12 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

4 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.5 acres
Built in 1950

Facts

Lot size: 0.5 acres

Rooms: 6

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Andrew D Lord	631-585-****	Residential status: Renter Job: Executive, Administrative, and Managerial Occupations Email: [email protected]
Kathleen A Lord Age: 70	631-585-****
Kerri E Lord Age: 49	631-585-****	Residential status: Renter Job: Executive, Administrative, and Managerial Occupations

Learn more

14 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 14 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

6 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.38 acres
Built in 1965

Facts

Lot size: 0.38 acres

Rooms: 8

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

14 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Sold $313,945

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Carol Antonucci	631-580-****
John H Groom Age: 52	631-585-****
Karen L Groom Age: 50	631-585-****
Amy M Jongebloed Age: 47	631-585-****
Bruce J Jongebloed Age: 74	631-585-****

Learn more

15 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 15 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

5 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.44 acres
Built in 1955

Facts

Lot size: 0.44 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Stacey L Gatto	631-495-****	Residential status: Renter Job: Production Occupations Email: [email protected]
Dolores M Puntillo Age: 97	631-588-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Executive, Administrative, and Managerial
Eugene Puntillo	631-588-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Executive, Administrative, and Managerial
M Puntillo	631-588-****
Mary I Puntillo Age: 72	631-588-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Executive, Administrative, and Managerial

Learn more

16 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 16 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

4 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.37 acres
Built in 1964

Facts

Lot size: 0.37 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Brick

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Joseph O'loughlin		Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administrative Support Occupations, Including Clerical Occupations
Marilyn O'loughlin Age: 87		Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administrative Support Occupations, Including Clerical Occupations
Stephen E O'loughlin Age: 87	631-981-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Administrative Support Occupations, Including Clerical Occupations Email: [email protected]
Marilyn A Olaughlin	631-981-****
Joseph A Oloughlin Age: 55	631-981-****

Learn more

17 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 17 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

4 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.5 acres
Built in 1953

Facts

Lot size: 0.5 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Mehmet Ekinci	631-580-****
David H Lemp Age: 48	631-580-****
John D Lemp Age: 45	631-580-****
Esref Ozsoy	631-580-****
Harry R Lemp Age: 78	631-585-****

Learn more

18 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 18 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

2 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.25 acres
Built in 1956

Facts

Lot size: 0.25 acres

Rooms: 5

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Wood

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Bror Bjorkstrom	631-585-****
Sylvia Bjorkstrom	631-585-****
Robert D Roach Age: 63	631-585-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Production Occupations Email: [email protected]
Richard Roach Age: 63	631-553-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Production Occupations

Learn more

19 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 19 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

4 beds
2 baths
Lot: 0.86 acres
Built in 1951

Facts

Lot size: 0.86 acres

Rooms: 7

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Doreen Concannon
Tracy Liardi
Doreen A Vinnem Age: 65	631-467-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Machine Operators, Assemblers, and Inspectors Occupations
Kenneth S Vinnem Age: 74	631-467-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Machine Operators, Assemblers, and Inspectors Occupations

Learn more

20 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 20 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

2 beds
1 bath
Lot: 9,583 sqft
Built in 1956

Facts

Lot size: 9,583 sqft

Rooms: 6

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Parking: Garage - Attached, 0 space

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
George M Walsh	631-467-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Food Preparation and Serving Related Occupations
Theresa A Walsh	516-467-****

Learn more

21 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 21 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

Lot: 0.64 acres

Facts

Lot size: 0.64 acres

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Henry J Beukelaer	631-585-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Healthcare Support Occupations Email: [email protected]
Veneta S Beukelaer Age: 82	631-585-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Healthcare Support Occupations

Learn more

22 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4205

Alternative address: 22 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4205

4 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.32 acres
Built in 1969

Facts

Lot size: 0.32 acres

Rooms: 11

Stories: 2 story with basement

Exterior walls: Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Parking: Off street, 0 space

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Jennifer N Bartosik
Joe Bartosik Age: 67
Joseph Bartosik
Bob Grant Age: 76
Sussan Leidner	631-981-****

Learn more

23 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 23 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

3 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.64 acres
Built in 1963

Facts

Lot size: 0.64 acres

Rooms: 6

Stories: 1 story with basement

Exterior walls: Wood

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Claire L Bellucci	631-737-****
Rocco Bellucci Age: 74	631-546-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Service Occupations Email: [email protected]
Timothy Bellucci Age: 48	631-546-****	Job: Private Household Service Occupations

Learn more

25 Firdale St, South Setauket, NY 11720-4215

Alternative address: 25 Firdale St, Centereach, NY 11720-4215

3 beds
1 bath
Lot: 0.64 acres
Built in 1964

Facts

Lot size: 0.64 acres

Rooms: 6

Stories: 2 story

Exterior walls: Brick

Who has lived here

Resident	Phone Number	Additional info
Dominick A Peluso		Industry: Business Services at Non-Commercial SiteNonclassifiable Establishments	See Details
Ann Peluso Age: 53	631-467-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Protective Service Occupations Email: [email protected]
Anna M Peluso Age: 88	631-467-****	Residential status: Homeowner Job: Protective Service Occupations
Annmarie Peluso Age: 53	631-467-****	Job: Production Occupations
Deborah Peluso	631-467-****

Learn more

All Market Activities Residents Comparison graphs

Market Activities

To date, we have no information about market activities in 2025

Jun 2023 Listed for sale

7 Firdale St

Price history :

$459K

Single Family
1,868 sqft
4 beds
2 baths

Mar 2021 Sold

2 Firdale St

Price history :

$556K

Single Family
4 beds
3 baths

Sep 2017 Sold

4 Firdale St

Price history :

$402K

Sep 2016 Sold

17 Firdale St

Price history :

$245K

Single-Family Home
0.5 acres
4 beds
2 baths

Jul 2016 Sold

17 Firdale St

Price history :

$260K

Single-Family Home
0.5 acres
4 beds
2 baths

Jul 2016 Sold

17 Firdale St

Price history :

$387K

Single-Family Home
0.5 acres
4 beds
2 baths

Jun 2016 Sold

14 Firdale St

Price history :

$314K

Single-Family Home
2,126 sqft
0.38 acres
6 beds
2 baths

May 2016 Sold

22 Firdale St

Price history :

$350K

Single-Family Home
1,800 sqft
0.32 acres
4 beds
2 baths

May 2016 Sold

22 Firdale St

Price history :

$358K

Single-Family Home
1,800 sqft
0.32 acres
4 beds
2 baths

Apr 2016 Sold

22 Firdale St

Price history :

$359K

Single-Family Home
1,800 sqft
0.32 acres
4 beds
2 baths

Apr 2016 Sold

22 Firdale St

Price history :

$360K

Single-Family Home
1,800 sqft
0.32 acres
4 beds
2 baths

Mar 2016 Sold

14 Firdale St

Price history :

$318K

Single-Family Home
2,126 sqft
0.38 acres
6 beds
2 baths

Mar 2016 Sold

14 Firdale St

Price history :

$328K

Single-Family Home
2,126 sqft
0.38 acres
6 beds
2 baths

Incidents registered in Federal Emergency Management Agency

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025

17 Nov 2014 Fire, other

3 Firdale St, South Setauket NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

13 Aug 2014 Electrical wiring/equipment problem, other

25 Firdale St, South Setauket NY

Property Use —

1 or 2 family dwelling

Firdale St, South Setauket NY

Residents

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Facts

Who has lived here

Market Activities

Incidents registered in Federal Emergency Management Agency

Comparison graphs

House prices on 1-25 Firdale St, South+Setauket NY

Total rooms, bathrooms and bedrooms on 1-25 Firdale St, South+Setauket NY

Lot size and building area (in sqft) on 1-25 Firdale St, South+Setauket NY

Where is Firdale St, South Setauket NY located on map?